I recently read a brisk discussion on Facebook about whether Democrats could be friends with Republicans. Many posters, liberals all, felt that Republicans are just too close-minded and cold-hearted to be friends with. Republicans are other.
Before I married John, I was inclined toward those posters’mindset. My parents were liberals. My mom boasted that her first election was Franklin Roosevelt’s first election, and she proudly voted for him in four presidential elections. My dad, nominally a Republican, had a liberal bent and turned solidly against the Vietnam War before it was even on my radar. So I come by my Democratic leanings honestly.
Coming of age in the late sixties as I did, my political identity is important to me. It caused me, when I was younger, self-righteously to condemn (at least in my head) people to the right of me – supporters of war and racism and police violence, unsympathetic to the poor, narrow in their social and religious attitudes. I’m still sometimes tempted toward these biases.
But I’ve been in recovery ever since 1978, when I married into the Ewing family. For over thirty years, I’ve had to break bread with Republicans, worship with them, swim with them, vacation with them, and open Christmas presents with them. Observing them at close hand, I couldn’t help but notice how nice they were. Nicer, I couldn’t help noticing, than me.
I’ve been thinking about these matters in connection with my father-in-law Stan, who died on Tuesday at the age of 90. One of the first things I heard about him, circa 1975, had to do with a political argument. He was telling John, during Sunday brunch, that Nixon wasn’t so bad. He had just gotten caught. My mild-mannered boyfriend, who’d already strayed from the Republican fold, had to leave the table to end the argument and compose himself.
But I don’t want to talk politics. I want to talk about kindness. I want to recount some of the stories that keep recurring in my mind – stories that illustrate his goodness and sometimes downright sweetness.
When Stan came to visit me in the hospital after I gave birth to our son, the first grandson in the family, his cheeks were wet with tears. The biggest Indians fan on earth had come bearing a little baseball-uniform onesie and a big stuffed baseball.
In January, 1983, I went on strike with other teachers in my district. The Ewings aren’t wild about unions in general and don’t approve of teachers striking. During that long, cold, harrowing strike, my mother-in-law watched my baby son while I picketed in the mornings, and my father-in-law Stan never breathed a word of criticism to me about striking. Through it all, my in-laws continued their habit of calling us on Friday nights to take us out to dinner.
My mother-in-law died suddenly right before Christmas in 1993. Christmas was her thing, and she always purchased a sweater (among many other gifts) for each member of the family. That sad Christmas, we gathered soberly at the Ewing home on Christmas morning, and the women of the family all got a package from Stan. Each contained a lovely sweater he had picked out himself.
Stan used to send me Mothers Day flowers and personalized cards, with certain words, like “love†and “special,†underlined.
My son reminds me that when my mom died in 1995, Stan, then a widower, came to her funeral and to the restaurant afterwards with my family. When my sisters and I asked the waitress for the check, she told us it had already been taken care of.
I suppose someone might say that anyone can be nice to family members and friends. What’s important instead is “systemic change†and the big picture and the huge problems of poverty and the environment and war and peace, and maybe they’re right. All I know is that Stan’s thoughtfulness, generosity, and simple love for his family have humbled and inspired me.
Thanks for the comments, everyone!
Kathy and John,
First, our deepest sympathies to you as you mourn your loss.
What a touching tribute to your father-in-law! We know so many dear friends from the other side of the political aisle but have earned a permanent place in our hearts. May you always cherish your memories of Stan.
Benoy and Sue Joseph
I’ve never been able to see, in day-to-day behavior, any party-difference in people. We just get different magazines than they do.
Thank you for sharing this story of my dad. He would be touched. Love, Barb
And here I thought I was the only “democrat” in the family! It’s “wonderful” that we can disagree with one another and yet still find common ground and get along. I wonder how that can grow and develop so maybe we can solve some problems in the world. We need more people in this world like Stan and his family!
The service was very moving today. Thank you for letting Chris and I be a part of everything.
Dear Kathy,
First of all, please accept our condolences to you and your family for the loss of your father-in-law.
This piece is an awesome account of your relationship with your in-laws. God bless them for loving you and caring so much about you throughout the years.
It is much about how family members and friends treat each other that will ultimately make a difference in our society. Politics is a dirty word and just an excuse for arguing over everything until something has to get done.
Gregg and I do it all the time. We don’t agree on politics and we don’t agree on what to eat for dinner … but we always manage to find something to eat when we’re hungry!
Thank you for sharing your thoughts and sentiments for all to read.
love, Leda
Very nice story, Kathy. I enjoyed reading it and thanks for sharing!!