Weekend Editions

My husband has a knack for naming film series. The Cleveland Cinematheque’s current schedule, for example, includes a series of nine movies by W.C. Fields cleverly dubbed “Fields Days.” Another series featuring a Swedish female director named Mai Zetterling is called “My, My, Mai.”

Because of his uncanny talent, I gave John the task of naming my Friday posts, intended to be about books and reading. He suggested “Fiction Fridays,” but I told him that I might want to write about non-fiction or poetry. After a few more false starts, he came up with “Weekend Editions,” which, though lacking alliteration, affords me a space to spill into Saturdays and Sundays. Opportunities to procrastinate are always welcome.

My husband expressed only one caveat. “Hopefully you won’t receive a cease and desist order from NPR,” he warned. Until I hear from the NPR lawyers, Weekend Editions will be closing out my blogging week, following Monday Meals and language and etymology on Word Wednesdays.

This week I’ve been thinking about a trend in popular culture featuring characters with Asperger’s syndrome or exhibiting traits of autism. Think Sheldon Cooper and Amy Farrah Fowler on TV’s “Big Bang Theory” and Claire Danes in the film “Temple Grandin.” If these portrayals can avoid becoming offensive and also help viewers learn about and accept differences, then that’s a good thing.

The Maid, a novel by Nita Prose, was recommended by someone I enjoy on YouTube. Knowing nothing else about it, I checked the book out of the library. On the first page, the narrator, Molly, a maid at a fancy hotel, says, “I’ve got simple, dark hair that I maintain in a sharp, neat bob. I part my hair in the middle—the exact middle. I comb it flat and straight. I like things simple and neat.” I certainly don’t begrudge people on the spectrum having a chance to see themselves on screen or in fiction, but I’ll admit to a sinking feeling as I read these lines.

It seems to me that characters with Asperger’s syndrome have become a little too prevalent, a little trite, a little commonplace. In this novel especially, Molly’s quirks become a heavy-handed novelistic device. You imagine a writer thinking, Unreliable narrators are interesting, right? What if our narrator had trouble reading other people’s intentions? What if she were deceived by nefarious people and framed with a crime? A genius could probably make this premise work. Here, though, Molly’s relentless misapprehensions seem exaggerated.

The Curious Incident of the Dog in the Night-Time, Extremely Loud and Incredibly Close—certainly autism and novels sometimes mix well. However, if right now you Google “Asperger’s fiction” or “characters with autism,” as many as thirty or forty titles pop up. Maybe you can think of examples yourself. At what point, I wonder, does a bona fide trend become merely trendy? Let me know what you think.

This entry was posted in Books, Weekend Editions and tagged , , . Bookmark the permalink.

3 Responses to Weekend Editions

  1. Kathy says:

    I have an idea where to go with this. Thanks, Sarah. I have a growing list of ideas for Word Wednesdays right now, including “redacted” and “affadavit”! May have to expand into other days of the week!

  2. Sarah Becker says:

    Suggestion for Word Wednesdays: words formed from Latin for day; diet (deliberative assembly) from “a day’s journey”; diet (food eating regimen) from “manner of daily living”; dial, from “wheel revolving daily’; diary; and probably many more. Not to be confused with English words beginning with dia- but related to di-, meaning “two.” Hope to hear your wisdom on this!

  3. Roger Talbott says:

    I am, first of all, glad to see this series of blogs unfolding. Great name, John!
    Glad you weighed in about fiction built around neurodivergent characters.
    One of my neurodivergent relatives, who is so incredibly smart that she wasn’t diagnosed until she was almost 40, would suggest that we are currently grasping for and creating a language to to convey this experience that has been surrounded by silence — just as we are doing in the area of sexuality and gender.
    It may be that the trend that you are seeing is seeking that language. I hope that some geniuses will engage with this. But, I suspect it will be the source of a lot of pulp and create new stereotypes before we get there. I guess that literature needs to be judged on whether it hurts people or creates more understanding.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *